The MethodSteps of The MethodResearcher



   
  Quality Assurance  
   
 
The alternative method's results have been submitted to analytical quality assurance since its original conception, through a critical comparison of the results, using the cold vapor technique coupled with atomic absorption spectrometry, besides participating in inter-laboratory exercises coordinated by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) and the use of control samples with known concentrations in the test routine.

From January 2002 to January 2006 we participated in inter-laboratory exercises coordinated by the CFIA, as part of the Mercury Quality Assurance Program (MQAP). This program aimed to guarantee the quality of test results for mercury in fish. Four unknown samples were sent to participating laboratories around the world (50 laboratories on average) and analyzed within a deadline set by the Program coordinators. The consolidated results underwent statistical analysis and the report was then sent to the laboratory for self-evaluation. The table below shows the comparison of the consensus results and the results of the semi-quantitative method, demonstrating its efficiency. Unfortunately the MQAP was suspended in January 2006, and we are currently studying the possibility of joining another similar program.
 
   
 
Comparative Results of Fish Sample Analysis through Participation in Inter-Laboratory Exercises Coordinated by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Jan. 2002 to Jan. 2006
 
   
 
Sample
Result Obtained
Consensus Result
Consensus Range
308
300-600
282±46
190-374
309
300-600
390±52
286-494
310
>1000
2209±388
1433-2985
311
300-600
289±46
197-381
312
300-600
391±45
301-481
313
600-1000
611±73
465-757
314
300-600
390±42
306-474
315
>1000
1101±197
707-1495
316
300-600
477±64
349-605
317
300-600
380±49
282-478
318
600-100
1116±161
794-1438
319
<300
281±42
197-365
320
<300
215±34
147-283
321
<300
405±61
283-527
322
300-600
438±75
288-588
323
300-600
630±89
452-808
324
300-600
525±73
379-671
325
600-1000
603±81
441-675
326
300-600
305±40
225-385
327
>1000
1236±190
856-1616
328
300-600
207±27
153-261
329
600-1000
375±45
282-462
330
<300
550±62
427-674
331
300-600
849±135
579-1119
332
<300
299±47
205-393
333
300-600
523±68
387-659
334
>1000
817±119
579-1055
335
600-1000
1217±174
869-1565
340
100-300
303±49
205-401
341
300-600
554±96
362-746
342
300-600
838±105
628-1048
343
300-600
502±90
322-682
356
~300
205±39
127-283
357
600-1000
508±91
326-690
358
>1000
1131±221
689-1573
359
600-1000
596±119
358-834
360
~300
503±76
254-446
361
300-600
602±92
455-763
362
~300
320±64
186-402
363
300
514±77
360-668
364
300-600
414±51
312-516
365
100-300
203±26
147-259
366
300-600
404±53
298-510
367
600-1000
577±79
419-735
368
600-1000
782±94
594-970
369
~600
494±60
374-614
370
~300
280±33
214-346
371
~600
399±47
305-493
372
~600
503±76
351-655
373
~1000
767±141
526-1030
374
~300
367±73
231-455
375
100-300
231±46
147-307
 
   
   
 
Copyright - © 2006 Allegra's Method. All rights reserved.